I made this Nutella Peanut Butter Pie last month by special request, for my Granddaughter Maddie’s birthday. Now that the kids are getting older, more and more often they are requesting non-traditional birthday treats instead of cake. I first made a couple of these pies last year for the Christmas holiday and forgot to share the recipe with you then. I had pulled this recipe from a magazine years ago, and am so glad I held onto it. It clearly made quite an impression on 12 year old Maddie, because this was the only sweet treat she desired for her birthday this year. The pies were sliced and devoured so quickly at her party, that I didn’t have an opportunity to snap an image of the inside of the pie. You’ll have to trust me that these pies are deliciously creamy and delightful on the inside as well.
This recipe makes two pies, and believe me you’ll want to have more than one. You can use a store bought graham cracker pie crust or a chocolate cookie crust. I couldn’t make up my mind between the two, so I used one of each. These pies are so simple and quick to whip up, much unlike the puppy party birthday cake we made for Maddie a couple of years back.
Nutella Peanut Butter Pie
Ingredients
- 2 9 inch store bought Graham Cracker or Chocolate Cookie pie crusts
- 1 8 oz block cream cheese softened
- 3/4 cup Creamy Peanut Butter
- 3/4 cup Nutella
- 1 cup Powdered Sugar
- 2 8 oz. or 1 (16 oz.) container of Cool Whip
- 1/2 cup Semi-sweet chocolate chips
- Chocolate Flavored syrup
Instructions
- In a mixing bowl, cream together softened cream cheese, peanut butter, powdered sugar, and Nutella. Once well combined, add in 8 oz. Cool Whip, slowly combining until mixture is smooth.
- Stir in semi-sweet chocolate chips.
- Divide mixture evenly between 2 pie crusts.
- Frost each pie with the remaining 8 ounces of Cool Whip.
- Decorate the top of each pie with chocolate flavored syrup. You can create a pretty pattern by swirling the chocolate syrup in a circular fashion from the center of the pie and working outward. Then, using a pointed kitchen knife or toothpick, lightly pull the syrup from the center out, to create stripes.
- Optionally, decorate with a few additional semi-sweet chocolate chips.
- Keep pies chilled in the refrigerator until ready to serve.
Sign-up for a FREE weekly newsletter for the best of Betty! Get exclusive access to up to $250 per year in coupon savings, free samples every month, the hottest recipes and more!
Nutella Peanut Butter Pie
Ingredients
- 2 9 inch store bought Graham Cracker or Chocolate Cookie pie crusts
- 1 8 oz block cream cheese softened
- 3/4 cup Creamy Peanut Butter
- 3/4 cup Nutella
- 1 cup Powdered Sugar
- 2 8 oz. or 1 (16 oz.) container of Cool Whip
- 1/2 cup Semi-sweet chocolate chips
- Chocolate Flavored syrup
Instructions
- In a mixing bowl, cream together softened cream cheese, peanut butter, powdered sugar, and Nutella. Once well combined, add in 8 oz. Cool Whip, slowly combining until mixture is smooth.
- Stir in semi-sweet chocolate chips.
- Divide mixture evenly between 2 pie crusts.
- Frost each pie with the remaining 8 ounces of Cool Whip.
- Decorate the top of each pie with chocolate flavored syrup. You can create a pretty pattern by swirling the chocolate syrup in a circular fashion from the center of the pie and working outward. Then, using a pointed kitchen knife or toothpick, lightly pull the syrup from the center out, to create stripes.
- Optionally, decorate with a few additional semi-sweet chocolate chips.
- Keep pies chilled in the refrigerator until ready to serve.
Related articles
This looks amazing. Sure to fill my sweet tooth craving.
This sounds Gooood! I like that it makes two pies,one to eat and I think I would freeze the other for another time!Anything with Nutella is pretty rich tasting!
Nutella makes everything so yummy. This looks good, its also so easy and quick to make, will be testing this out.
Shhot me now, that looks awesome & has all my faves 😛
Ohhhhh… And just yesterday my husband bought the HUGE jar of Nutella. I told my oldest daughter I was gonna HAVE to make something. THIS Looks delish!
That looks amazing…so it must taste amazing, too!
I heart Nutella!
I love chocolate pie, peanut butter and chocolate so I bet I’d love this!
ahhhhhh nutella peanut butter is a wicked combination!!
This looks picture perfect!!! YUM!
This is so pretty I almost wouldn’t want to cut into it but I would LOVE to try this one. Thanks for sharing the recipe I want to tackle this one.
Love how it looks. I’ve never made anything with Nutella, my daughter is the only one that eats it.
This looks wonderful! I have to tweak recipes to fit the allergies in my household, and this gave me some great ideas
I can easily imagine how good this must be! 🙂
That looks delightfully good!
One of my favorite combinations of flavors! This is dangerous.
This recipe looks amazing! Nutella and Peanut Butter are two of my favorite sweet treat ingredients.
that looks incredible! can’t wait to try it. pictures turned out beautiful!
YUM! I love nutella and peanut butter. I’d love to try this.
Gorgeous! I can’t wait to try this for my kids. It looks so yummy. 🙂
So much yum in one pie!! I definitely will be making this asap!!!
When I worked in the office I always liked it when we did something other than a cake for birthdays. We even did ice cream one time.
This looks like it would have a taste that’s off the charts. I’m not much of a baker so I am going to give recipe to my friend. Thanks
Yummmmm! I must try this!
Oh boy, this pie does it for me. It looks wonderful, and I’m sure if you were able to get a picture of the slice, it would be so enticing! I love Nutella and peanut butter – I never thought of putting them together Not hard to make, either, this is a good one for teens and/or a buffet! Wow!
That almost looks too pretty to eat! I have never tried nutella before…. I think I am missing out
Okay, I must finally try nutella and make that pie!!!!
My MIL makes a recipe similar to this and it is rich and chocolaty. It looks beautiful!
That looks delicious!! Love the design on the top too!
you are speaking my language – peanut butter & nutella. It doesn’t get much better than that!
I so wish I could try this right now, but such is life on a sugar detox.
Mmmm. Yes please! Two of my favorite things in one!
Oh m goodness this is beautiful.
i love nutella and am always looking for recipes that call for it. this sounds delicious and so easy!!!
I used to be OBSESSED with Nutella — and then I got sick on it in my first trimester. I’m hoping my love reappears after the baby is born!
Can’t go wrong with Nutella! This looks so tasty! My Father in Law would love it!
This looks and sounds AWESOME! Almost to pretty to eat, just stare at it all Day.
Thanks for the Post, Picture, and the Recipe!
It looks beautiful. I think I am the last one in the world that hasn’t tried Nutella. I am resisting. I don’t need another addiction.
Oh my goodness! I am definitely making one or both of these pies for my youngest granddaughter who eat and breathes Nutella! She is so picky with her diet except for Nutella; so, anything I can make her with this ingredient will have her blessing!!
That sounds delicious! I need to try that.
This really looks delicious! This would be a great dessert for me to make for our family Thanksgiving! My family loves a chocolate – peanut butter flavor combination!
Well, that got me craving chocolate and peanut butter! Yum
Oh sweet heavenly pie! This is like all of my favorite deliciousness in one mouth watering dessert.
Oh this sounds amazing!! I love anything made with Nutella and Im a huge fan of Pb! I may try this this coming weekend!
I love everything about this pie… but you had me at Nutella!
I’m pinning this for my daughter, because she is obsessed with Nutella! She’ll love this if I make it for her when she visits!
My sister is beyond in love with Nutella, I might have to make this for her birthday in January!! She would be in heaven!
Wow, that is beautiful and sounds delish!
Oh wow, that looks amazing. I’m not a fan of peanut butter, but OMG I love Nutella so I might just have to try!
Looks divine! I wish I’d seen this a week ago instead of now. I just came back from the doctor who told me to drop thirty pounds to accomplish some health goals.
I’m not a nutella fan, but I wonder if I’d like it in this pie!
Your pie sounds yummy and looks really great. I wish mine were that presentable :)) This is like making a rum cake though; no more nutella by the time I have to put it in 😉
That looks delicious!! And SO EASY! Thank you!
this looks so yummy…. and I have not yet tried nutella I think this will be the time too try it!
We make something similar, but it isn’t as presentable.
This looks so awesome and looks every easy to make
A few of my family members just love Nutella and peanut butter, alone, mixed together, it doesn’t matter so I think this pie is for them. I will be sharing the recipe for sure!!! Thanks!
Mmm…who could resist. I think I gained 5 pounds just by looking at it, but in all seriousness it looks and sounds to die for.
I think I might finally nudge my sister’s Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie from the top favorites position at the holiday supper .. adding Nutella will be an unexpected flavor as I do not think many in my family have tried it .. me, I could eat this tasty hazelnut spread out of the jar with a (very large) spoon.
OMG you are killing me girl. I cannot have Nutella in my house as it is as I will eat the whole thing. No lie. I have seen all kinds of pies with Nutella lately.